Skip to main content

Report Writer under managed COBOL?

  • Aug 11, 2016 9:21 PM UTC
  • 6 replies
  • 28 views

Does anyone know of any restrictions or issues with using Report Writer in managed COBOL? Does anyone have any experience with Report Writer in managed COBOL? We've converted a number of our "batch" COBOL programs to managed code with success, but this is the first one that uses Report Writer and an exception is being thrown at the C# call to COBOL class (within a rununit) that reminds me of Net Express errors I saw YEARS ago when a compiler bug created bad references that wouldn't link. The exception is "Method not found: 'Void COBOLPrograms.WYE39P._MF_IMPLICIT_1()'". We are running VC 2.3.1 for VS 2013 Update 5. COBOLPrograms is the COBOL class library targeting .NET Framework 4.5 with Debug/Any CPU configuration. WYE39P is the converted COBOL program (public) with only the Linkage Section and Procedure Division code residing in the single Method-ID named InstanceMethod. We aren't getting any compile errors. And we haven't run it from a server, just within the IDE. Questions? Comments? Ideas?

6 replies

Dominique Sacre
Forum|alt.badge.img+2
Does anyone know of any restrictions or issues with using Report Writer in managed COBOL? Does anyone have any experience with Report Writer in managed COBOL? We've converted a number of our "batch" COBOL programs to managed code with success, but this is the first one that uses Report Writer and an exception is being thrown at the C# call to COBOL class (within a rununit) that reminds me of Net Express errors I saw YEARS ago when a compiler bug created bad references that wouldn't link. The exception is "Method not found: 'Void COBOLPrograms.WYE39P._MF_IMPLICIT_1()'". We are running VC 2.3.1 for VS 2013 Update 5. COBOLPrograms is the COBOL class library targeting .NET Framework 4.5 with Debug/Any CPU configuration. WYE39P is the converted COBOL program (public) with only the Linkage Section and Procedure Division code residing in the single Method-ID named InstanceMethod. We aren't getting any compile errors. And we haven't run it from a server, just within the IDE. Questions? Comments? Ideas?

I don't have any experience with Report Writer in managed or unmanaged COBOL, I'm afraid. However, my initial guess is that a generated method needs to be decorated with the MicroFocus.COBOL.Info.Callable attribute. You could try adding "attribute Callable" to the method-id in WYE39P, along these lines:

method-id InstanceMethod attribute MicroFocus.COBOL.Info.Callable.

You might need to add that attribute declaration to the class-id as well.

If that fixes it, then you should ask your support rep to raise an RPI against Report Writer, I think.


  • Aug 12, 2016 4:55 PM UTC
Does anyone know of any restrictions or issues with using Report Writer in managed COBOL? Does anyone have any experience with Report Writer in managed COBOL? We've converted a number of our "batch" COBOL programs to managed code with success, but this is the first one that uses Report Writer and an exception is being thrown at the C# call to COBOL class (within a rununit) that reminds me of Net Express errors I saw YEARS ago when a compiler bug created bad references that wouldn't link. The exception is "Method not found: 'Void COBOLPrograms.WYE39P._MF_IMPLICIT_1()'". We are running VC 2.3.1 for VS 2013 Update 5. COBOLPrograms is the COBOL class library targeting .NET Framework 4.5 with Debug/Any CPU configuration. WYE39P is the converted COBOL program (public) with only the Linkage Section and Procedure Division code residing in the single Method-ID named InstanceMethod. We aren't getting any compile errors. And we haven't run it from a server, just within the IDE. Questions? Comments? Ideas?

The suggestion didn't fix the exception.  I tried modifying the method-id first and tested, then modified the class-id and tested again.  Same exception thrown at the C# call to the COBOL class.  Maybe for a better picture, here is the C# code from our program called COBOLRunUnit.cs:

bool bError = false;

string sLine = "";

string sOutput = "GOOD";

string param_control = "data to be passed to WYE39P";

MicroFocus.COBOL.RuntimeServices.RunUnit myRunUnit = new MicroFocus.COBOL.RuntimeServices.RunUnit();

try

{

   WYE39P myCobol = new WYE39P();

   myRunUnit.Add(myCobol);

   sOutput = myCobol.InstanceMethod(ref param_control);

   if (sOutput == "ERROR") { bError = true; }

}

catch (Exception ex)

{

   bError = true;

   sLine = "****      ERROR:" ex.Message.ToString();

}

While single-stepping through this code, pressing F11 at "sOutput = myCobol..." causes the cursor to jump to the catch.  There is a breakpoint set on the first executable COBOL statement in WYE39P, but we never get there.

Also note:  As soon as I modified the method-id in WYE39P, the "WYE39P"s in the C# statement "WYE39P myCobol = new WYE39P();" underlined with a red squiggle.  In fact every statement making this type of assignment in this C# program "red underlined" and the Error List tab showed a first message:

"The type or namespace name 'COBOLPrograms' could not be found (are you missing a using directive or an assembly reference?)"

followed by one message for each call to a COBOL class:

"'COBOLRunUnit.COBOLRunUnit.[program name](string)' is a 'method' but is used like a 'type'".

Do I still open an RPI, or does this give someone another idea of where we have gone over the cliff?


Dominique Sacre
Forum|alt.badge.img+2
Does anyone know of any restrictions or issues with using Report Writer in managed COBOL? Does anyone have any experience with Report Writer in managed COBOL? We've converted a number of our "batch" COBOL programs to managed code with success, but this is the first one that uses Report Writer and an exception is being thrown at the C# call to COBOL class (within a rununit) that reminds me of Net Express errors I saw YEARS ago when a compiler bug created bad references that wouldn't link. The exception is "Method not found: 'Void COBOLPrograms.WYE39P._MF_IMPLICIT_1()'". We are running VC 2.3.1 for VS 2013 Update 5. COBOLPrograms is the COBOL class library targeting .NET Framework 4.5 with Debug/Any CPU configuration. WYE39P is the converted COBOL program (public) with only the Linkage Section and Procedure Division code residing in the single Method-ID named InstanceMethod. We aren't getting any compile errors. And we haven't run it from a server, just within the IDE. Questions? Comments? Ideas?

I haven't had to use run units in managed COBOL myself, so I'm afraid I don't have anything else to suggest. I can only recommend you contact your support representative.


Chris Glazier
Forum|alt.badge.img+4
Does anyone know of any restrictions or issues with using Report Writer in managed COBOL? Does anyone have any experience with Report Writer in managed COBOL? We've converted a number of our "batch" COBOL programs to managed code with success, but this is the first one that uses Report Writer and an exception is being thrown at the C# call to COBOL class (within a rununit) that reminds me of Net Express errors I saw YEARS ago when a compiler bug created bad references that wouldn't link. The exception is "Method not found: 'Void COBOLPrograms.WYE39P._MF_IMPLICIT_1()'". We are running VC 2.3.1 for VS 2013 Update 5. COBOLPrograms is the COBOL class library targeting .NET Framework 4.5 with Debug/Any CPU configuration. WYE39P is the converted COBOL program (public) with only the Linkage Section and Procedure Division code residing in the single Method-ID named InstanceMethod. We aren't getting any compile errors. And we haven't run it from a server, just within the IDE. Questions? Comments? Ideas?

Hi Don,

Please open up a support incident and attach a demo program and we will take a look.

Thanks.


  • Aug 17, 2016 7:18 PM UTC
Does anyone know of any restrictions or issues with using Report Writer in managed COBOL? Does anyone have any experience with Report Writer in managed COBOL? We've converted a number of our "batch" COBOL programs to managed code with success, but this is the first one that uses Report Writer and an exception is being thrown at the C# call to COBOL class (within a rununit) that reminds me of Net Express errors I saw YEARS ago when a compiler bug created bad references that wouldn't link. The exception is "Method not found: 'Void COBOLPrograms.WYE39P._MF_IMPLICIT_1()'". We are running VC 2.3.1 for VS 2013 Update 5. COBOLPrograms is the COBOL class library targeting .NET Framework 4.5 with Debug/Any CPU configuration. WYE39P is the converted COBOL program (public) with only the Linkage Section and Procedure Division code residing in the single Method-ID named InstanceMethod. We aren't getting any compile errors. And we haven't run it from a server, just within the IDE. Questions? Comments? Ideas?

I've opened incident # 2872555 and uploaded a .zip of the entire solution folder.


Chris Glazier
Forum|alt.badge.img+4
Does anyone know of any restrictions or issues with using Report Writer in managed COBOL? Does anyone have any experience with Report Writer in managed COBOL? We've converted a number of our "batch" COBOL programs to managed code with success, but this is the first one that uses Report Writer and an exception is being thrown at the C# call to COBOL class (within a rununit) that reminds me of Net Express errors I saw YEARS ago when a compiler bug created bad references that wouldn't link. The exception is "Method not found: 'Void COBOLPrograms.WYE39P._MF_IMPLICIT_1()'". We are running VC 2.3.1 for VS 2013 Update 5. COBOLPrograms is the COBOL class library targeting .NET Framework 4.5 with Debug/Any CPU configuration. WYE39P is the converted COBOL program (public) with only the Linkage Section and Procedure Division code residing in the single Method-ID named InstanceMethod. We aren't getting any compile errors. And we haven't run it from a server, just within the IDE. Questions? Comments? Ideas?

Thanks Don.

I have been able to reproduce the problem using a simplified version of your example that invokes the COBOL method from a C# console app without using RunUnits.

I find that the error occurs whenever the INITIATE statement is present in the method. If I comment this out then the call is successful.

I also converted the class into a COBOL program with a single entry point and I can invoke this entry point from the same C# program without a problem.

I have created an RPI for this and have passed it onto development for review.

Thanks.